Patents: GEX, InfiniQ, DX7

I apologize for not posting recently. I expended way too much energy on Yamaha Montage M. Don’t get me wrong, Montage M is a worthy subject and I gave it careful consideration as an 88-key piano solution for home. In the end, I decided to venture into Clavinova-land and have ordered a CSP-170. [That’s another story for another day.]

Gotta build energy for the GENOS2 launch in two weeks (November 15). 🙂

GEX keybed technology

I posted this short fresh take on the GEX keyboard technology at the Keyboard Corner forum. After learning more about the EM induction sensor approach, I felt the need to clarify.

The optical shutter sensing system is used in the older AvantGrand and SilentPiano instruments. The “Non-contact continuous detection electromagnetic induction sensor” is the latest Yamaha tech and will be delivered in the newer AvantGrand and SilentPiano models. GEX is derived from the EM induction sensor approach.

I’m still searching for information, but a recent Yamaha patent describes such a key articulation system. The key side has one or two coils of wire. The substrate (PCB) side has similar opposing coils. The circuitry senses flux direction, etc. on a key-by-key basis.

U.S. Patent 11,657,790 B2, Operation detection device for key operation of keyboard device, Kenichi NISHIDA, Harumichi HOTTA, Jun ISHII, May 23, 2023.

Yamaha’s latest patent is interesting because they want to measure “yaw” and “roll”, not just vertical “strike” distance. Couple this with their recent key/note articulation patents and you’ve got an “MPE” keyboard!

Quite possibly, they were not able to finish the keybed design and set up the manufacturing for these advanced designs. Thus, the m6 and m7 got FSX (for now). The Montage M team were probably ordered to “deliver or die in October 2023” by the suits. Concessions were made to meet schedule.

Sonuus InfiniQ position sensor

While investigating the GEX technology, I found the U.S. patent for the Sonuus InfiniQ position sensor. Sonuus deploy the InfiniQ sensor in their Voluum analogue effects pedal. The InfiniQ is based on electromagnetic induction, avoiding the usual potentiometer approach and its disadvantages.

U.S. Patent 8,933,314 B2, Musical effects devices, James Hastings Clark, Morag E. Clark, John M. McAuliffe, January 13, 2015.

I recommend reading the Sonuus patent because it is well-written — real English instead of the patent-ese written by American attorneys. The Sonuus patent provides useful background information about the applied science of electromagnetic induction.

Yamaha DX7 reverse engineered

I stumbled across a brilliant bit of DX7 reverse engineering by Ken Shirriff.

He created a composite die photograph of a decapsulated DX7 YM21280 OPS (operator) chip. Ken annotates and relates the die photo to U.S. Patent 4,554,857, explaining the operation of the DX7 OPS chip in detail. The YM21280 is driven by its brother, the YM21290 EGS (envelope) chip.

Quite frankly, this is fantastic work!

If you’re interested in how Yamaha implements FM (or FM-X) in hardware, you need to visit Ken’s pages and read the U.S. Patent on the DX7 internal design:

U.S. Patent 4,554,857, Electronic musical instrument capable of varying a tone synthesis operation algorithm, Tetsuo NISHIMOTO, November 26, 1985.

I also recommend the Yamaha DX7 Technical Analysis by ajxs.

Yamaha DX7 block diagram (U.S. Patent 4,554,857)

I will revisit Ken’s analysis when I have more energy. I fully expect, however, to see a modern day, scaled-up FM-X equivalent in the Yamaha SWP70. This — this! — is how Yamaha achieves 128 voice FM-X polyphony. Please keep this approach in mind when discussing what the SWP70 can do or what it can be extended to do. Montage/MODX FM-X ain’t code running on a RISC…

Copyright © 2023 Paul J. Drongowski

Montage M8x review: Yes, I played one!

Grabbed this week’s music binder and tried out a Yamaha Montage M8x for an hour. Overall, a good experience. The demo M8x was set up at Guitar Center with two Yamaha HS-8 monitors.

Here are my observations…

Pianos galore

I dove into the pianos first, because acoustic piano (AP) sounds and practice are my primary need at this time.

The CFX and Bösendorfer Imperial sounded good and clear. In fact, everything sounded good and clear. Might be due to the HS-8s being brighter than my studio monitors; might be due to Pure Audio Circuit 2 (PAC 2).

The Hamburg Grand — a Steinway, presumably — is brighter than I expected. It should cut through a band mix, no prob. Definitely a high-quality addition to the Montage range.

I briefly checked out the Nashville C3, the C7, and the Felt pianos just to verify that they are there. The audio definitely had more clarity than MODX or even Genos (gen 1).

I dove into the CFX grand programming. Yep, one part with 18 elements.

Yet, with all the acoustic pianos, something was missing. Don’t get me wrong, Montage M acoustic pianos will be great for the stage, especially if the pianist is competing with guitar, drum and/or other general cacophony. The APs don’t have the depth or dynamism that I hear in Clavinova, for example. Maybe it’s the missing VRM, Grand Expression Modeling, whatever. People still may choose to record exposed piano solos using virtual instruments or the real deal itself.

The user interface

If you’ve been using either Montage or MODX, be ready for change. It took a little while to come to grips with the new user interface (UI). I managed to navigate through AWM2 element programming and effects without too much trouble. However, old habits must change!

The main screen is clear and responsive enough. Much has been said about the touch screen response — didn’t bother me. I like the button matrix for voice selection. Very easy to use and I quickly depended upon it. Performance search is different and it required some trial, error and time before I became accustomed to it.

The sub display is beautifully clear and readible. Some people have been grumbling about pixel jaggies. Again, didn’t bother me. I’ll take that large display any day over the slim sub display on Genos. The large subdisplay allows BIG numbers and parameter names — good for stage work.

UI-wise, I’m on board with Montage M although one hour is not really enough to get the full sense of workflow.

Electric pianos

Montage M has new electric piano (EP) waveforms and performances. They beat everything I’ve played on MODX, Clavinova and Genos. I’m jealous and can’t wait to get my hands on these waveforms and voices on a ligher weight, more affordable gig instrument. My homework shows anywhere from 8 to 12 strike levels. Definitely top-notch.

Rotary speaker sim

I tried diving into the drawbar organs through the voice category buttons. Not the best idea as I kept running into old familier organ Performances. I dialed in a few Performance, heard swirlies and mentally shrieked, “No, no, this can’t be happening again!”

I suggest starting out in the “Best of Montage M” Live Set. Or, do a little menu diving to verify that you are hearing the new VCM rotary speaker sim. Familiar, old organ Performances continue to use the old ROTARY SPEAKER 1 and ROTARY SPEAKER 2 effect types.

Keep your eyes open and look for a big VCM rotary icon. The VCM icon pops up on the sub display as well as effect edit screens. For some reason, Montage M treats the VCM rotary sim as a separate effect block. You won’t necessarily find it in the Insert A or Insert B slots.

Once found though, you’ll be happy. Well, at least happier than Montage/MODX. I’d like it better if rotary speed could be switched by a pedal, right out of the box. It’s a long reach to the MOD wheel or ribbon controller on the 88.

GEX keyboard

AP and EP with GEX is satisfying. I would not call GEX “light.” The key weight felt similar to the GH3/GH3X — and left my hands somewhat tired, too. Crazy me, NWX or GrandTouch (wood, linear grading) remain at the top of my list.

Playing drawbar organ on GEX is a chore, but you probably guessed that already. Palm swipes are not fun. I could say the same for strings, woodwinds and the other non-piano voices which I auditioned. The lack of PAT on M6/M7 is a genuinely awkward subject for synthesists, organists, or people like me who spend a lot of gig time playing non-piano voices.

AN-X Performances

I didn’t invest a huge amount of time trying AN-X. I browsed the AN-X Performances in the “Best of Montage M” Live Set. The AN-X sound reminds me of the my old AN-200 groove box and why I love it. Maybe it’s just the patches that I tried, but the sound connected me to AN/VA back in the day — reminiscent of the Sequential Circuit Prophet upon which AN was modelled.

I would be very pleased to own a Montage M with AN-X. I’m more excited about AN-X, now, than FM-X. The AN-X Performances have a certain dynamism.

The F-word

At this point, I don’t give a fig. GC had classic rock on the PA and how are you going to listen for anything quiet and subtle during “Smoke on the Water”? So, all I can say is, “Make your choices.”

Where does this leave me?

This time around, I’m interested in getting the best digital piano experience that I can — for the money. I want good value and I’m not willing to spring for any old expensive 88.

The Yamaha Montage M series sound terrific. In person, they look terrific. Whatever 88 I buy will sit in our dining room. Therefore, visual aesthetics are important. As much as I like the look of Montage M8x and P-515 (P-525), a furniture digital piano is more appropriate for the dining room. All the dancing lights would entertain guests, but… Might as well rule out CP88, too, on aesthetic grounds.

The other issue is the GEX keyboard. It’s a good keybed, but I find the NWX to be more comfortable for extended play. I may be in a bit of trouble here as Yamaha seems to be phasing out NWX. The P-515 successor, P-525, for example, has a GrandTouch-S (wood) keybed.

As to sound, the Montage M series acoustic and electric pianos are damned good. I love the variety. (Same could be said of Stage CP since it’s roughly the same line-up.) The VCM rotary speaker sim is very welcome and long overdue. The acoustic piano sounds, however, are missing VRM and I don’t want to compromise. VRM definitely enriches the digital sound especially when you’re playing solo or practicing.

Not that it’s a GEX thing specifically, but I have real concerns about playing non-piano voices on a so-called piano action keybed. I play organ, strings, woodwinds, etc. daily on MODX (el-cheapo semi-weighted action) and Genos (FSX). FSX is still a decent compromise across a wide spectrum of voices. I think synth players will be happier with M6/M7. Even Yamaha pitch M8x as “M8x for the pianist.”

At this point, I will probably find a landing place in Clavinova-land. That doesn’t mean I dislike the Montage M series. On the contrary, I can’t wait for “MOM” or “MOMO”! My MODX6 is going to wear out eventually…

GENOS2 incoming, November

It’s official.

Still awaiting SEQTRAK™

Copyright © Paul J. Drongowski

Review: KApro London Symphonic Orchestra

While we were discussing Minutiae, Korg released the KApro Iconic Suite “London Symphonic Orchestra” expansion library for Korg Module:

KApro Iconic Suite “London Symphonic Orchestra” features the brilliant blockbuster sound of a large symphonic orchestra of up to seventy-seven musicians. It offers 17 diverse programs and 10 stereophonic multi-samples, encapsulating vibrant and expressive orchestral sounds, including the always popular strings, French horns, cinematic brass, woodwinds, choirs, and percussion layers typically found in cinematic soundtracks. [Korg]

It’s on sale from October 13 to October 20, 2023. Time is running out!

When I saw the introductory price of $6.99 USD — 7 bucks! — I didn’t bother with the 7 day free trial. And, I’m glad I bought it. I already have the KApro Cinematic Brass expansion pack and it is my go to for orchestral brass sounds. The LSO expansion follows in its footsteps.

Like many KApro offerings, the KApro LSO suite mainly consists of layered and switched combis. If I was required to use only one word, I would say “warm.” The timbre and textures are a perfect match for the liturgical music and situations that I play.

In terms of programs, here’s what you get:

    Switch Orchestra 1  Choir / Solo Strings
    Switch Orchestra 2  Choir / Brass / Timpani
    Switch Orchestra 3  Choir / Brass / Strings

    London Switch Orchestra 1  Horns / Strings / Timpani
    London Switch Orchestra 2  Horns / Solo Strings
    London Switch Orchestra 3  Wind Ens / Low Strings
    London Switch Orchestra 4  Wind Ens / Strings

    London Ponsardino 1  Slow swelling strings
    London Ponsardino 2  Slow swelling strings and brass 
    London Ponsardino 3  Slow swelling strings
    London Ponsardino 4  Slow swelling strings

    London Switch Chamber   Small string sections
    London Sordino Chamber  Small string sections
    London Switch Brass     Warm horns slow crescendo

    London Psychedelic      Tutti with slow pulsation
    Phased Chamber          Small strings/horn with slow phaser
    London iXperiment       Tutti through a ring modulator

All of the sounds are blended and I’m sure there are more woodwinds in the mix.

I’m not usually a fan of switched percussion. Only a few programs incorporate percussion, however. Timpani is mapped over a small range of keys and is triggered by high(er) velocity strikes.

The London Switch Orchestra programs are my favorites, especially the programs with the wind ensemble. Strings everywhere are warm and don’t have that high-end raspiness that grates on me. Very usable.

The so-called ponsardino programs all swell to full color. “Ponsardino” is not a standard musical term, by the way. I assume “sardino” refers to the use of mutes — no Jerry Bruckheimer brass, here.

If I had one knock on the expansion library, it’s the naming. I wish the program names were more descriptive. Nothing wrong with using one’s ears, but memory jogging program names would be helpful. Too many “switch” and “orchestra”; maybe abbreviate?

The KApro Premium EXs374 Iconic Suite London Symphonic Orchestra for Nautilus and Kronos is $49.99 USD. The Module version appears to be full fat (670MBytes) and is an absolute steal at $6.99. Recommended.

Copyright © 2023 Paul J. Drongowski

Montage M8x: Key notes

Yamaha rarely invent a new technology and not reuse the same tech in a different product line. So it goes with the key sensor tech in Yamaha Montage M8x.

We all got an important clue from the most recent Music Production Guide:

The model MONTAGE M8x features a newly developed, special keyboard called “GEX”, which supports Polyphonic Aftertouch. Unlike other keyboards, the GEX keyboard does not use conventional key contacts, but electromagnetic induction. With this technology, each individual key position can be continuously scanned. In addition, the keyboard supports software updates, which enables the future development of further techniques and articulations beyond Polyphonic Aftertouch.

GEX has its origins in the latest Yamaha hybrid and Silent Piano product lines. This might explain why Yamaha brought out Polyphonic Aftertouch (PAT) in the 88-key version of the Montage M series and not M6/M7 Quite simply, Yamaha could use components and a keybed that were already sitting on its shelf.

This blog post is a bit of a clip-show. I’m collecting information about the sensor technology and want to share a few starting points for further reading and exploration.

Three types of key sensors

Yamaha have three major key sensor technologies in use today:

  • 2- and 3-contact rubber key strips — the most-widely used type,
  • Non-contact 2-point optical fiber hammer/key sensors — employed in hybrid, Silent Piano™ and Transacoustic™ pianos, and
  • Non-contact continuous detection electromagnetic induction sensor — the latest tech.

I won’t be saying much about the rubber key strips because this technology is so well-known.

Electromagnetic induction key sensors

Yamaha announced its new line-up of TransAcoustic and Silent Piano models in August 2022. As part of the announcement, Yamaha briefly described a newly developed “Articulation Sensor System.”

We have newly developed an electronic “Articulation Sensor System”. Wireless communication from sensors installed under all 88 keys allows for natural playing without sacrificing the piano’s original touch. In addition, it is now possible to always accurately grasp the movement of keys being pressed and released, and to detect minute movements of the keyboard, such as when playing staccato, more accurately than before.

Specifications for the SH3 and SC3 Silent Pianos identify the key sensing system as “Non-contact continuous detection electromagnetic induction sensor.”

The new Yamaha Montage M8x employs the latest electromagnetic induction key sensing technology in its GEX keyboard.

Previously, Transacoustic and Silent Pianos employed contactless, optical hammer and key detection. As you can see from its description below, the optical key sensors require much labor and costly components. The gradient optical key shutters must be carefully aligned.

The new electromagnetic induction key sensors appear to be easier to build and install. Each key has small inductive loop on the bottom. Sensors on the printed circuit board below the keys detect loop (key) movements.

Because the electromagnetic induction sensors are so new, it will be some time before we learn the details about the new sensor technology.

NU1XA AvantGrand

When I heard “electromagnetic induction” and “hybrid” fall out of Blake’s mouth, I instantly remembered the Yamaha NU1XA hybrid piano. The NU1XA combines an upright’s key action with digital synthesis. The Yamaha Articulation Sensor System is described in the following way:

The NU1XA features our newly developed Articulation Sensor System, which accurately and continuously captures the pianist’s subtlest performance nuances, through non-contact electromagnetic sensors and Yamaha’s proprietary algorithm. This system utilizes two separate sensors on each key: one for the hammer — the most crucial part of the acoustic piano sound mechanism — and the other for the key itself, to precisely measure the movement of finger release and articulate exactly the special nuances when the sound stops. Together, they fully capture the most delicate expressions of the player. [Yamaha]

Obviously, the Montage M8x does not have hammers and Montage M8x has only under-key sensors. [Needs to be verified.]

Yamaha NU1XA key action and sensors [Yamaha]

Yamaha have been working to simulate the interplay between a pianists fingers (and pedals) in order to “craft changes in timbre according to the speed and depth with which the keys are pressed.” Yamaha calls these proprietary algorithms and software “Grand Expression Modeling.” Like Montage M PAT, the Yamaha secret sauce is in the software.

This technology goes well-beyond simple 2- and 3-switch discrete sensing into the realm of continuous sensing. You’ll find 2-switch sensing in most other Yamaha synths and arrangers. 3-switch switch sensing is found in so-called “triple sensor” keybeds like GH3, GH3X and NWX.

Optical shutter key sensors

Key sensor and greyscale shutter [Yamaha]

Under each of the 88 keys is a Yamaha-unique continuous-detection grey-scale shutter key sensor. These sensors detect the movement of the keys continually, allowing natural musical expression even when the piano is in SILENT Piano™ function. Since they do not come into contact with the keys, these sensors do not affect the feel of the keyboard in any way. [Yamaha]

I’m sure all of this Yamaha tech is patented. Happy hunting at the USPTO!

[Update: Thanks to Jason at the Yamaha Synth Forum who found these two Yamaha patents: U.S. Patent 5612502A and 6121535.]

Silent Piano optical sensors

The old Yamaha Silent Piano™ line use continuous key and damper pedal detection. Key sensing uses optical shutters.

Yamaha Optical Key Sensors [Yamaha]

Yamaha Silent Pianos go one step further than the hybrids — Silent Pianos are complete pianos with action, strings and soundboard. When a Silent Piano is switched to Quiet Mode, the hammers are stopped before hitting the strings. The articulation sensor system tracks key movement, sending data to Grand Expression Modeling and tone synthesis. [The Quiet and Acoustic Modes are selected with a silencing lever or pedal.]

If you use information from this article, please post a link to my site. Thanks!

Copyright © 2023 Paul J. Drongowski

Montage M: Fan on, fan off

When my nephew was four years old, he was positively obsessed with fans. Whenever the forced-air furnace would kick on at my sister’s house, he would immediately say, “Fan on!” When the furnace kicked off, we’d hear “Fan off!” We always knew the status of the heating system.

Later in life, he became obsessed with helicopters…

Please, give the Yamaha Montage M fan discussion a rest. I’m sorry that I ever said anything about it. 🙂

Having crawled through all things electronic from Raspberry Pi-sized devices to 1960s-sized mainframes — and maintained them — the small CPU fan in the Montage M series is not a matter for concern. As many people pointed out, Korg Kronos, Apple Macbook Air and other popular products have small fans. Usually, these fans are variable speed and throttle down (or off) depending upon CPU load.

I’m sure someone will mention fan-less tablets and phones. Apple, Samsung, etc. have carefully considered thermal design and are depending upon the metal body to carry away the heat into free space. (Or your hands.) Phone and tablet designers don’t get a free pass either.

The scientifically astute people correctly cite physics. You want to compute, you got to spend power. You want faster, you’re going to need more power. Think “Scotty and the dilithium crystals.” 🙂

You may not know it, but this site has all of the lecture material for my university-level courses on computer design and VLSI systems. Check it out!

I always did a section on cooling and power estimation because, in hardware, design has three major concerns: speed, space and power. Most software types think solely in terms of program speed and size. The fact that software consumes gobs of power when it runs, is not normally taken into consideration by programmers.

There is a simple formula to estimate CMOS dynamic power dissipation:

                                         2
    Power     = Capacitance     * Voltage   * frequency 
         dyn               Load          DD

The power supply voltage is normally fixed for the given fabrication technology, e.g., 3.3 Volts. Capacitance is the aggregated capacitance of all the transistor gates and wires which must be switched between 0 Volts (logic 0) and +3.3 Volts (logic 1). The frequency is the clock frequency.

If you go multi-core, you have more transistors and wires, and the aggregated capacitance is higher than single-core. If you increase the clock frequency, the transistors will switch on and off more often. So, if you want a multi-core processor with a high clock rate, you’re gonna pay in dynamic power dissipation. In plain terms, you’re going to generate more heat.

That heat needs to go somewhere. High-speed CMOS circuits get incredibly hot if the heat is not removed (dissipated). Get above 60 or 70 degrees Celsius and you’re flirting with disaster. Prolonged operation at high temperature is unreliable leading to circuit failure. Even modest overheating shortens circuit life in the long run.

Having seen the guts of Yamaha products, I have confidence in their engineers. I’m sure they have chosen the appropriate cooling solution. Some people are yakking about passive cooling with tubes and plumbing junk. Save that for your gaming machine. With manufacturing concerns and cost in mind, frankly, give me a friggin’ break.

To put things in better perspective, the picture below is the Raspberry Pi cooling system provided by Canakit. There are two heat sinks: one for the external memory IC and one for the CPU. The cooling fan is optional. Taken together, this cooling solution is sufficient for a Broadcom BCM2711 quad-core ARM Cortex-A72 at 1.5GHz. Montage M doesn’t need much more than that.

CanaKit Raspberry Pi cooler (and American quarter)

Please note the small size of the fan: about one inch (2.54cm) per side. This is not an x86-size cooler!

Yes, there are practical matters in the studio. You should be controlling the amount of dust (and smoke!) in your studio simply to keep your key contacts and connectors clean. Next, I can relate to noise concerns having used a Silver-door Mac for many years. [Hurricane force winds!] The dinky fan in the Montage M should be barely audible. I doubt if you will track it — unless you put a mic next to the fan and sample it. 🙂

“No spoiler.”

Copyright © 2023 Paul J. Drongowski

Montage M APs and EPs

I’m starting to compare Yamaha Montage M waveforms against Montage/MODX waveforms.

Montage M acoustic (AP) and electric pianos (EP) got a very big bump! The table below has my raw, working notes.

    Montage       Montage M      Strike levels
    -----------   -----------    ---------------
    CF3 Stretch   CF3 Stretch    3       Soft/Med/Hard
    CF3 Flat      CF3 Flat       3       Soft/Med/Hard
    S6 Stretch    S6 Stretch     4       pp/mp/mf/ff
    S6 Flat       S6 Flat        4       pp/mp/mf/ff
    CFX           CFX            9    
    S700          S700           3       pp/mf/ff
    Upright       Upright        3       mp/f/ff
                  C7             5       pp/mp/mf/f/ff
                  Nashville C3   5       p/mp/mf/f/ff
                  Imperial       8    
                  Hamburg Grand  10    
                  U1 Upright     5       p/mp/mf/f/ff
                  Felt Piano     4       p/mp/mf/f
    CP70          CP70           1 
    CP80          CP80           5       p/mp/mf/f/ff
                  CP80-2 Attack  4       mp/mf/f/ff
    
    EP1           EP1            3       Soft/Med/Hard
    EP2           EP2            2       Soft/Hard
    EP3           EP3            2       Soft/Hard
    EP4           EP4            5       p/mp/mf/f/ff

    Rd Soft       Rd Soft        5       p/mp/mf/f/ff
    Rd Hard       Rd Hard        4       mp/mf/f/ff
    Rd73          Rd73           5       p/mp/mf/f/ff
    Rd78          Rd78           5       p/mp/mf/f/ff
    Wr1           Wr1            3       Soft/Med/Hard
    Wr2           Wr2            4       p/mf/f/ff
    Wr3           Wr3            5       p/mp/mf/f/ff

                  67Rd           9    
                  73Rd Studio    8    
                  74Rd Stage     10    
                  78Rd Studio    10    
                  Wr Warm        12    
                  Wr Wide        10    

The Hamburg Grand is nicely detailed with 10 velocity levels. Given the change in waveform name, the CFX might (emphasis, “might”) have been refreshed. We should ask Yamaha about that. Yamaha are making good use of the new 128 element per part capability.

I can verify that the U1 Upright, Nashville C3 and Felt pianos in the character piano give-away are full fat (i.e., same number of strike levels as Montage M).

The Yamaha talking points don’t mention it much, but there are new Rhodes and Wurlitzer waveforms. And, they are beautifully detailed. There’s a new CP80, too.

I didn’t spot any changes in sampled DX, Clav, drawbar, combo, and pipe organ waveforms. Why update sampled DX when Montage has FM-X? Duh.

This is all pretty spiffy for AP and EP players. I hope some of these waveforms trickle into Genos2 and the Clavinova digital pianos. I’d love to see that Hamburg Grand in the (much anticipated) CLP-800 series. Throw in a few of the new EPs along with the Hamburg and Yamaha will tempt a lot of upgrades.

Given the range of pianos in Montage M, one wonders about the future of Stage CP (mark 2). Perhaps Stage CP will adopt technology from the Clavinova line — Virtual Resonance Modeling (VRM), in particular?

Copyright © 2023 Paul J. Drongowski

Montage (M)usings

Just in case you don’t have enough to read, here are links to the latest Music Production guides:

It’s raining in The PNW (as usual) and I’ll kick back with these as should you.

Now for a few random thoughts.

Got the power

I owe (Another)Scott for this observation. He found the following error message in the Yamaha Montage M Operation Manual:

CPU Fan Error: The instrument internal cooling fan has stopped.

CPU fan?

Yes, CPU fan. Demonstrators and punters alike have noted the snappy, responsive Montage M performance. As I thought, Yamaha have upped the host CPU in Montage M. We’ll have to wait for pictures or service manual, but I suspect multi-core (Montage gen 1 is a single core ARM) and/or a higher clock speed.

This means more power in and more power (heat) out.

I wouldn’t expect to find a massive, x86-sized blower and heat sink. Even lowly Raspberry Pi 3 (Broadcom BCM2837 quad-core ARM Cortex-A53 at 1.2GHz) needs a small cooler when running compute-intensive jobs. Raspberry Pi coolers are modestly small and light.

The new Montage M CPU probably includes a more up-to-date, integrated graphics processor, too. It would be interesting to know if the graphics processor (GPU) speeds up the Smart Morph operation. Inquiring minds want to know!

Sub display

I loves me that big old 512×64 LCD “sub display” and the way it is integrated with the rest of the Montage M workflow. The Montage M engineers took this idea from Genos “Live Control” and made it bigger and better in every way.

The Genos host CPU (AM4376 ARM operating at 1GHz) handled its sub display over a relatively slow, 2MHz Small Peripheral Interface (SPI) bus.

This got me thinking and speculating. The Yamaha SWX09 processor (248MHz internal clock) has a heavy weight DSP, integrated display interface, and low(er) resolution analog-to-digital converters. What if an SWX09 handles the sub display, scans the knobs and sliders, and performs AN-X synthesis? That structure and assignment of duties would make AN-X synthesis incredibly low-latency and responsive to knob and slider control. The SWX09 would need to send controller values over the E-bus to SWP70 and other destinations.

Please file this speculation under “daydreams.”

AWM2/FM-X tone generation

If I had to guess (and I will), Montage M has two SWP70-type “Standard Wave Processors” just like Montage gen 1. AN-X is computed by either an SWX09 or an SSP3. Both SWX09 and SSP3 are SH-2 RISC cores. The SH-2 has been a Yamaha stalwart for nearly two decades, appearing throughout a wide variety of products from audio interfaces, to mixers, to Reface, to digital pianos.

Here’s food for thought. In Montage gen 1, the Master SWP70 handles AWM2. The Master SWP70 has two wave RAM channels: one populated, one empty (“not installed”). Perhaps — perhaps — Yamaha populated the second wave RAM channel and doubled the size of the NAND flash from 4GB to 8GB.

The fly in the ointment is the stated Montage M AWM2 polyphony spec: 128 factory preset elements plus 128 user waveform elements. If both operate from the same NAND flash, then there should not be this artificial split (factory vs. user). Perhaps Yamaha added user NAND flash and wave RAM to the Slave SWP70? Or maybe this is all wet and there is a third SWP70? (See Genos internals.)

128 elements per part

As I mentioned yesterday, allowing up to 128 elements per Performance part is a big win for piano and organ voice programming. In Montage gen 1, sound designers often needed to split voice elements into several Parts, 8 elements per Part (max).

This improvement opens a can of worms with respect to real-time element assignment and activation. The E-bus carries note on/off directly from the keybed scanner to the Master SWP70. How much does the host CPU intervene? Does the SWP70 handle element assignment and activation by itself? If the SWP70 does this by itself, then Yamaha probably needed to revise the SWP70 IC, i.e., a new silicon spin and a new part number (“SWP71”).

BTW, just for kicks, someone should try programming a Performance Part with 128 elements. Hit a note, then hit a second note. What happens?

Fun with fuses

Some folk still conceptualize SWP70 as “a big ole programmable CPU”. I prefer to conceptualize the SWP70 as a collection of AWM2 pipelines, FM-X pipelines, 32 or so very simple DSP effect processors, and a very flexible digital audio mixing system. (Of course, there’s other stuff, too.) The AWM2 pipelines and FM-X pipelines are circuits dedicated to AWM2 and FM-X synthesis, respectively and specifically.

Each group of pipelines reside on their own power and clock grids. Circuit fabrication is not a perfect process. The AWM2 pipes or the FM-X pipes could suffer a fabrication flaw. During QA, Yamaha could sort parts into four categories: both AMW2 and FM-X good, AWM2 good and FM-X bad, AWM2 bad and FM-X good, both AWM2 and FM-X bad. Both sides bad is a reject.

In the cases of one side good, the bad side can be fused off. Yep, there may be fuses to cut bad pipes from the power and clock grids. Parts can be assigned to either AWM2-only duty or FM-X-only duty when a PCB is manufactured.

This is standard industry practice. The processor you are using right now probably has bad circuits fused off!

E.S.P. all over again

Dedicated pipelines are why Yamaha tone generators and polyphony are so predictable and stable. There isn’t any nonsense about effects, this or that cutting into polyphony because everything shares the same processor.

That’s why I don’t expect the Expanded Softsynth Plugin (E.S.P) to provide stellar polyphony. The initial release (“early 2024”) will support sound design. That’s a modest goal for PC-/MAC-synthesis. I wouldn’t expect too much — “all the Montage M sound while being limited to basic editing.” The full version is planned for Summer 2024.

As to development, pricing and distribution, I’m sure Steinberg will have a hand in. Steinberg completed a rent-to-own partnership deal with Splice in April 2023. Yes, Steinberg and Yamaha have caught the subscription model disease. If it’s rent-to-own, the price isn’t going to be cheap. You didn’t expect to get a Montage M for a few bucks, did you? You want to play, you gonna pay.

Copyright © 2023 Paul J. Drongowski

Yamaha Montage M8x: Initial take

Well, my site got hammered last night while I was trying to live blog a few details from the Yamaha Montage M documentation. Thanks for visiting SSS.

Yamaha Montage M6

By now, everyone has downloaded the documentation and watched Blake’s Take on the Montage M. There isn’t a need to rehash that information here. Below are a few comments which are “value added”, I hope.

Bread and butter

The Montage M sound demo should assure long-time users that Montage M continues to cover the basics. I don’t think the AN-X demos in the video will get pulses racing among the cultists. If anything, the Montage M is the all-rounder that we wanted six years ago!

Those prices

Montage M pricing is in premium keyboard territory:

    Model          MSRP     MAP
    -----------   ------  ------
    Montage M8x   $4,999  $4,500 USD
    Montage M7    $4,499  $4,000 USD
    Montage M6    $3,999  $3,500 USD

Minimum Advertised Price (MAP) is what you will see on-line, of course. I wouldn’t expect much wiggle room for negotiation while the Montage M is hot. You might be able to find an open box unit after the Fickle Freds return ’em.

Even the M6 is a step up from the gen 1 Montage6. Gulp.

Elementary

Montage M AWM2 Normal Parts may have up to 128 elements. The old limit was eight. This gives punters a way to create massive stacks within a single element. Or, you can shrink those multi-part performances into a single part. I did this recently in order to make a MODX Performance Seamless Sound Switching (SSS) eligible.

Getting rid of the old limit enables single-part, multi-strike pianos with more than eight velocity levels — among other uses.

Me, the tech nerd, wonders if removing the limitation is software-only or if the AWM2 hardware was revised (i.e., SWP71). Get out your screwdrivers!

AWM2 polyphony is split between factory presets and user waveforms. Knowing what little I do know about SWP70, Yamaha may have enabled the second, unpopulated waveform memory channel in the Master SWP70. Or, maybe they went the Genos way. Montage M may have two SWP70s still; AN-X is either an SSP3 or SWX09. Screwdrivers, anyone? Take good pictures while you void your warranty.

The rotary speaker effect

Montage M gets the Virtual Circuit Modeling (VCM) rotary speaker effect which was added to Stage YC in the V1.2 update. The algorithm has three main variations:

  • VCM Rotary Speaker Classic: Standard rotary speaker effect
  • VCM Rotary Speaker Overdrive: Simulates the distorted sound of a rotary speaker with a transistor preamp connected
  • VCM Rotary Speaker Studio: With three-dimensional rotation

I’m still trying to get my head around the VCM rotary effect routing. It appears in the insert signal chain (below), but is listed as its own effect block in the Data List PDF.

There is also a limitation. The VCM Rotary Speaker Switch parameter is available only for Part 1. According to the Operation Manual, “Only Part 1 of the VCM Rotary is enabled. All other Parts cannot be used.” Hmmmm.

Fortunately, you can put all of the drawbar elements into a single part (i.e., Part 1). That should phase-align the rotary speaker across elements. Drawbar sounds are generated by AWM2, FM-X or AN-X. No modeling.

I still can’t find a satisfying effect routing diagram in the manuals. Grrr. Further, the routing screen above, IMHO, is a jumble.

Them pianos

The Montage M is fat with pianos: CFX, C7, Nashville C3, CF3, S6, S700, Imperial, Hamburg Grand, U1 Upright, Felt. A few of these pianos were released as a parting gift to existing Montage (and MODX) users. On voices alone, CP88 is in bad need of an upgrade.

I haven’t spotted any significant additions to the EP line-up — yet. I need to cross check the Montage M waveform list against gen 1. I’m looking for improvements to the orchestral instruments, too. Frankly, I don’t care about Performances named “Flowerpot Hats” (or whatever) because what the heck do they sound like? They are what they are. 🙂

Doing a thorough comparison takes time and caffeine. I’ll get around to the task someday…

Am I gonna buy one?

“M8x for the pianist”

My primary need right now is a digital piano for practice. I would love to get my hands on a Montage M8x and test drive the new GEX keybed. I want to know how it measures up against GrandTouch (wood plus counterweights) and NWX.

Here’s a few considerations. The price of M8x is comparable to a mid-range Clavinova CLP or CSP. The Clavinova digital pianos have Virtual Resonance Modeling (VRM), Grand Expression Modeling, triple-pedal unit, and built-in sound system. Montage M, at a minimum, demands an external sound system, a robust stand (62 pounds!) and a bench.

There is also the aesthetic side, namely, furniture versus stage instrument. I’m out of studio space and my next purchase will reside in one of our common living spaces, the so-called “dining room.” Guess which alternative wins with spouses? 🙂

Bottomline: The Clavinova digital pianos remain attractive. Yamaha P-525 is an even better value after its bump from P-515, although the visual aesthetic is not as appealing as Clavinova. Just for piano, M8x is a difficult sale.

E.S.P.

The Expanded Softsynth Plugin (E.S.P.) provides an “in the box” version of Montage M.

The Yamaha Montage M series press release has further information about the Expanded Softsynth Plugin (E.S.P.):

MONTAGE M series keyboards come with a download code for the Expanded Softsynth Plugin (E.S.P.) for MONTAGE M, which is a software synthesizer (VST3, AU) that can replicate all MONTAGE M series sounds, offering more powerful stage and studio integration.

We are planning on releasing E.S.P. in early 2024. The first version will have MONTAGE M sound, while being limited to basic editing. The full version is planned for release in summer 2024.

Notice that the first version will be limited to basic editing.

I suspect that E.S.P. started out as a prototyping and development tool for Montage M. Shoot, Montage runs on Linux, why the heck not? Mid-stream, the team decided to productize E.S.P. A good ideaâ„¢.

However, I doubt if E.S.P.’s polyphony spec will be very good. It’s hard to replace several hundred hardware tone generation channels and effect DSP units with software. You’re still going to want to buy hardware. Just sayin’…

Copyright © 2023 Paul J. Drongowski

Happy birthday, Montage M!

Sunday was our grandson’s birthday party. At age six, this kid is already an automotive gearhead. We watch car racing and Motortrend together. “No street racing!” — your Mom said so. [And, go to college!]

I got him a spiffy red Ferrari 812 Competizione. Lego, of course, his other love.

Kid takes one look. Says, “No spoiler,” and moves on to the next gift.

Think that one over. 🙂

Montage M (emulated)

Thanks, again, to Saul at Yamaha Musicians Forum. Quoting:

Yamaha has created a software version of the Montage M. This is a 1:1 emulation with all features present.
My understanding is that the software will come free with the purchase of a new Montage M but that it will also be available as a standalone purchase.

Of course, this raises many questions about capabilities, end user licensing, distribution, pricing, yada-yada. We’ll know soon. BTW, only n00bs launch a new product on a Monday. 🙂

Back in April, Steinberg announced a “rent-to-own” partnership with Splice. Could the new partnership bring the emulated Montage into fruition?

Will the emulated Montage M interoperate with Yamaha’s new control surface?

Flash: Major leakage

A few highlights from the Hispasonic article.

The Expanded Softsynth Plugin (E.S.P.) provides an “in the box” version of Montage M. Available in January (at no cost to Montage M users), E.S.P. provides hardware and software integration (editing, use of sounds, etc.)

AN-X polyphony is 16 voices (as rumored). The basic voice architecture includes 3 oscillators, noise source, double filter section, ring and FM modulation, autosync, PWM, 2/4-voice unison modes.

Each AWM2 part of a performance can stack up to 128 elements. AWM2 polyphony is doubled. The 8-part limit on Seamless Sound Switching (SSS) remains.

Montage M factory AWM2 preset sounds (7,620 multi-samples) occupy 10GB of memory when converted to 16-bit linear format. USER flash memory space is 3.7GB (presumably uncompressed). The article refers to an additional 128 voice polyphony when playing from USER flash memory — which is similar to Genos (gen 1).

FM-X polyphony remains 128.

Yamaha Pure Analog Circuit (PAC) is improved with better mids and bass.

As rumored, only the M8x model gets polyphonic aftertouch. The M6 and M7 have channel aftertouch. (Probably FSX keybeds as before.)

Overall, the Hispasonic article repeats, confirms or amplifies the most recent leak. I’m still waiting to see the manuals, especially the Data List PDF. The analog cultists hate everything already.

A few other random comments. A separate leak claims “VCM Rotary Speaker effect and realistic drawbar behavior deliver authentic organ control and sound.” Well, as far as eight sliders will take you, anyway. I think this means flipping the slider behavior. Maybe Yamaha ported the Stage YC rotary speaker effect to Montage M? That would be welcome on both Montage M and Genos (mark 2).

Wonder where all the preset waveform memory went? The “Best of Montage M” screen lists four pianos: CFX Concert, Ballad Piano, Hamburg Grand and Imperial. Pianos notoriously chew through sample memory.

The pictures aren’t up to Yamaha PR quality (resolution). Seem kind of home-brew. That carpet is hideous. I tore out one like it from our first house — 30 years ago. 🙂

Copyright © 2023 Paul J. Drongowski